My dad reached out to me today and asked if I wanted to go for a walk tomorrow. I am considering it.
I responded to him, we could, but I am still angry.
He asked me a number of assumed positions, "angry you didn't feel heard? angry that you didn't feel any empathy for your cause? Angry that our perspective is different?"
I replied yes, and more.
I took irritation with the way he asked the questions. It's one thing to predict/assume and try to demonstrate empathy by understanding what someone else might be experiencing... it's another when you use terms like "your cause" -which distances and minimizes given the context.
My cause is humanity, what do you mean?
At the exact time he was texting, I went to Raising Canes on the twin cities campus, passing one hotel that was protested and disrupted because they were housing ICE, and while there, walking to another. The only indicators of any disruption what's so ever was one of those police monitoring things. It fit into the busy area and didn't stand out. The other hotel had their curtains drawn on the front side of the building, but one could easily blame that on the sunny weather. Whether it was insurance or whether the damage wasn't extensive, there was literally no impact within a day. That can't be said for those whose lives are upended.
I did the little walking tour, because I was homing in on the moment in which I became furious during the argument a week ago. The first moment (there were a few).
I brought up the impacts of the occupation, they argued that it might be offset by the spending ICE did, I pointed out that it couldn't do that, and that the impacts were not spread to those hurt by the federal government. My stepmom shifted the focus to the *bad people on both sides. I was thinking about the way she did that, shifting the narrative from immigrants being hurt and agents doing the hurting, to a narrative that centered herself.
"I am afraid to go out because of the protestors" "I saw the damage they did to a hotel."
That moment made me furious in an instant and I couldn't even name why in the moment. In hindsight I identified basically three things A) you made yourself the victim (which brings up our relationship/family history), B) You equated your fear as being the same as those who are hiding for their lives, and C) you stated that property is more valuable than humans.
I got up at that point, ready to walk out, but I continued to argue, shaking in my anger, and that's when the conversation shifted to Alex Pretti and Renee Good, and my stepmom and dad both saying that they were in essence responsible for their own deaths because they shouldn't have been present, or interfered, or had a gun. Bringing up a D) those who stand against injustice are in the wrong and deserving of death (which was implied not stated), and that those who carry out the injustice are not responsible (again implied). I argued amongst these statements that being shot 10 times in the back is absolutely not justified and the implication was wrong, and that the fact that there is no investigation is a demonstration of who is in the wrong and should be held accountable. They continued arguing. I walked out because in that moment it became enormously clear that they were in essence backing the fascist government and the propaganda they have seen rather than acknowledging that the government should be held responsible.
So
A) making yourself the victim, and centering the narrative on yourself
B) equating the minor consequences to yourself to the enormous impacts on others
C) stating that property is as important or more important than humans
D) backing fascism rather than those fighting against it.
A) has been something I've tiptoed around since I was a child, having to change my behavior to make these adults more comfortable rather than acknowledging my own discomfort. My stepmom and dad have a long history of this... and I have a long history of backing down, accepting they are flawed and trying to find areas of agreement.
B) Could be ignorance if I assign the best possible motives
C) Could be a poor choice of words without realizing the implications if I assign the best possible motives
D) Could be ignorance (like literally not understanding history or what's happening in the world) OR a survival strategy (going along to try to escape the suffering others are experiencing), OR trying to hold onto power at the expense of others.
I think the difficulty is that A and B and D (and C with a little added assumption) easily line up to D3.
What's the counter to that?
My dad and stepmom have a long history of selfless acts. They were both social workers/educators or adjacent in their work. They donate to food shelves and good causes. They know and help out their neighbors. For many years they attended a black church. They have mentored and supported lots of folks who were down and out. All of this very much in the vein of The Blind Side (except my family doesn't have a lot of money -see social work).
I spent many years arguing with them around politics, despite doing similar work in the world. Perhaps they are just hyper local, loyal to the immediate family and neighborhood. I have always said, in some ways they are more welcoming, sometimes more supporting and even more giving than my liberal side of the family.
And yet, that giving or support is based on their interests, their investments, what they get out of it. EG my dad showed up to the sports games, and brought me to plays and stuff, but only when it didn't interfere with his stuff -which early on was a major issue with my stepmom, because her stuff became his stuff and suddenly, he was late to pick us up, and early to drop us off, or didn't show up at all.
My dad puts his lawn mowing business ahead of time spent with others... telling himself it's because of the need for money or whatever but then spending less quality time around the people he is spending that money on. Even getting resentful of time spent with others because it is interfering with his business.
My stepmom (and dad) are literally doing day care for my stepsister all week. 2 little kiddos, and they create a good space for them. But at the same time, is this why she is so ignorant to what's happening outside of her home and neighborhood? Are the protestors scary because she has become isolated and agoraphobic ... meanwhile her daughter's students and their families (stepsister is a teacher) are hiding in their homes afraid that if they leave, their entire lives will be completely upended, that they may never see a loved one again, that they may be tortured or killed.
The reason the whole convo started is that my stepsister had asked if we could support one of her students' family's businesses, and my stepmom was complaining (after she left) that she didn't like that type of food (hence me naming the impacts on businesses in the area).
The problem with this is that they have a history of underhanded comments against people of color, poor folks, liberals etc... supporting Republicans and Trump, supporting policies that undercut the communities they claim to care about, even their own jobs. For example, the school-business partnership that my stepmom was so proud of working for to support students who had disabilities join the workforce, was or is being cut my trump/republicans, those students and their families are losing benefits, the special ed and at-risk youth my dad served are also being depleted of their resources... Meaning, literally if they were still in the workforce, they'd have lost their jobs. Not to mention all the other horrible things... but I mean to point out that even when it directly hurt them and the people they claimed to serve/care about, they didn't see it/or chose to vote against their own interests.
You'd think that two people with health issues who are in retirement or semiretirement would pay more attention to things like medicare, but I guess even when their own skin is in the game, they acquiesce to the man? ?? I dunno.
I find my dad to be really difficult to pin down. Sometimes I know him to be a really warm and giving person, willing to problem solve and work things out. Other times, manipulative, sneaky, dishonest, distant, standoffish, cold, bitter... Sometimes I think he is performing the good guy role/the peacemaker, and then resents everyone for it.
I see so much of that in myself. I think often that is why I find it so deeply offensive. Throughout this whole ordeal I keep recognizing my own hypocrisy and my own guilt. I also live in denial, choose my battles, manipulate, try to keep the peace, and then when things don't go my way, I have acted out, been disgruntled, mean, hurt people, put my needs and desires before theirs. I too choose who I serve, and don't show up for others... I justify it. I write off great swaths of humanity because it's too hard to hold everything. I see it. I am it. I hate it.
I can recognize my own guilt even in this relationship conflict. I was hiding my values and beliefs to keep the peace and letting them do it too. I was choosing work and my values over quality time relating to my family. I was showing up for others in my community rather than showing up for 'my own.'
I can see all the ways that my hurt and anger impact the story I am telling myself... and yet, I am still angry and hurt. Still questioning... and maybe ultimately it isn't some grand political civil war (though it does feel possible we will be on opposite sides if it comes to that)., maybe it is that our experiences and values fundamentally shift the way we operate in the world... and it hurts not just because they are different, but because the ways in which they are different are not complimentary, and not always compatible... they mean we will never have the relationship I desire. I won't be able to rebuild the trust fully. I won't be able to not walk on eggshells and avoid topics. There will always be distance between us, and I will have to limit my hopes, my seeking out, because there are actual limits to the capacity for our relationship. And that sucks.
And maybe that's what I need to accept. Maybe that is my childhood hope, and I need to stop responding the way I did when I was a child. No, I won't dumb down my feelings for you, if you want me around, expect that I will say some mean stuff because your actions are hurting me, and your lack of awareness means I can't get through any other way. Or maybe it means I'll have to be more distant, because your actions are hurting me, and I can't keep allowing that.
As I have said before, that has never aligned with who I am... this whole let's fight it out, or lets distance... I broke up with E because I was starting to get mean and I don't want to be that person.
I've made so many mistakes and lashed out so many times by trying to keep the peace, or trying to avoid the conflict, or being pushed to a point where I hurt myself instead of saying something. I can't keep doing that same old thing.
It feels like a point where I choose myself or choose relationship, and I haven't found a third option, but I am guessing it is somewhere in which there is less investment than I want... and I will just have to be sad about that.
I feel like this whole thing is about humanity, and recognizing it... and in some ways I just took that to the most personal level. Rather than being about george floyd, or alex pretti, or trump... just making it about me. I deserve to get to be me, and be loved and supported anyway, and thats not always possible in some relationships.
I think I want to go back to the personal responsibility thing though, I keep feeling so much guilt and regret about the ways I've acted on when I have tried to honor someone else instead of honoring me. I think this comes up with my dad because when I recognize all the years of hurt and pain, its so easy to say, yeah I did it because I loved him... but at what cost? I am not saying my actions are because of him, I am saying I did horrible things that I've regretted most of my life because I lived out this pattern of hiding my anger... and it shaped me into a person like him. Someone who does stupid mean distrustful things because he hasn't been being honest in the first place.
I don't want to be that anymore. I am just so sick of it... I want to trust myself and who I am.
I keep thinking of the last few days with M, and how I was this epitome of this yuck... I was so convinced that I could help her, and so convinced that she was being dishonest with me, and I felt taken advantage of, and I'd put in so much effort to try to be helpful*? I dunno... to be what she needed me to be... that I had just utterly lost myself... and I was angry and resentful and possessive and gross.
With E, I knew I was starting to get resentful and angry... and I just couldn't do that anymore.
But I don't know how to live a life in which I am generous, and honest, and also IN relationship...
maybe with the exception of with friends... but even then, not always. And my world is shrinking soooo much.
I dunno... I guess I am just saying I don't know.
I am tired and its 11:40. But I also want to write about AI and fascism and stuff... Maybe another time.
But the reason I was thinking about it is because so many things have been hitting my feed lately that my pattern recognition or whatever that is, is just going off...
Its like, everything is lining up to be an entirely different world. And all the autistic folks I know have been screaming this for years... but these last few weeks I am like holy shit...
AI is replacing us now, not in the future, now. The government is systematically trying to dismantle all safety nets and safeguards: food standards, environmental protections, research that helps human beings, disease prevention, healthcare, education, on and on... the value of a human life is being erased in front of us... they are building concentration camps and deporting people, and arming a non military that is uneducated, untrained, brutal, masked, and unaccountable... this week they stripped Kansan trans folks of drivers licenses, they are threatening the elections and other voting rights... they are preparing for war but not telling anyone about it, overthrowing and extorting other governments, robbing the poor, reducing the standard of living and lying about all of it. To say we are in fascism or a dictatorship is naming the look and feel of it, but underlying is this really super sinister thing. They are erasing the value of humanity. Human rights? what human rights... Human life? what human life.
Literally the folks behind some of these AI/detention center schemes want to lock up 1/3 to half the population... or kill them.... because they are unnecessary to their idea of what society will be.
It will be the ultra-wealthy lording over a smaller group of serfs, and everything is heading in that direction simultaneously... with the exception of the community organizing that people are doing in protest... but they will burn us out, or lock us up... and then what?
We all imagine the world keeps growing and getting better like it has for a few generations... but it wasn't long ago that the wealthy openly profited off swings in the economy that might put 15% of the population back into extreme poverty over a weekend. (still happens around the world).
We have a hard time imagining in our lifetimes, a world in which the technology is even greater, but the majority are actually suffering not benefiting. We imagine a universal basic income... but why would they do that if it doesn't serve them?
Why be a billionaire amongst billions, when being a billionaire amongst a million who are in your control is so much more satisfying to the ego.
One of the ghouls of the admin, has literally said the US would be better with 100 million people not 320 million... deport, detain, death. In that extremely powerful monster's mind, 220 million people need their lives to be drastically changed for him to be satisfied.
"they're trying to build a prison, for you and me to live in." SOAD
Is it cowardice to leave for a better life? Or is that courage?